Skip to content
mental-health — Phones — Mental — Li — H2 — Alexandra — Science — Health-and-wellness

Children's smartphone usage doesn't align with common assumptions.

Cell phone usage by children may not be as harmful as previously believed

,   and  Administrator
3 min read
Nighttime mobile phone screen viewing should be avoided by children, as it's questionably...
Nighttime mobile phone screen viewing should be avoided by children, as it's questionably beneficial for their sleep patterns.

Clarifying Children's Phone Use: Separating Fact from Fiction in Mental Health Discussions

By Alexandra K.

  • ~ 5 min read
  • Phones
  • Kids
  • USA
  • Smartphones

Revealing the True Story

Children's mobile phone usage may not be as thoroughly understood as previously thought. - Children's smartphone usage doesn't align with common assumptions.

Simply put, the consensus on children's phone usage and its impact on mental health has taken a dramatic turn. It seems we've all been led down a garden path, or perhaps a digital one, of misunderstandings.

Let's Debunk Common Myths

Social Media: The Real Culprit?

Contrary to what we thought, social media platforms might be doing more harm than good to our youth. A Pew Research Center survey found that an astounding 44% of parents suspect that social media is the primary cause of the mental health struggles among their teens[1]. Meanwhile, teenagers themselves are starting to perceive social media as predominantly detrimental[1]. Moreover, studies show that heavy social media use by 11-13-year-olds often leads to increased depressive symptoms and anxiety[2].

The Sleepless Recipe for Woes

But social media isn't the only issue. Research also suggests that kids—and all people, for that matter—who spend too much time glued to their screens at night experience sleep problems, which can eventually snowball into mental health concerns[2].

A Silver Lining? Not So Fast

All is not lost, though. Studies have hinted that smartphone ownership, not just use, can potentially lead to some positive outcomes. For instance, ownership may be associated with lower feelings of depression and enhanced social interaction among 11-13-year-olds[4].

Debating the Timing Game

So when should we hand over those chrome-clad slabs of connectivity to our children? There's a fiery debate raging among experts about the ideal age for kids to immerse themselves in the digital world. Some argue that delaying exposure until they're, say, 16 could be good for their mental health[3]. But others argue for a more moderate approach, stating that a wait-and-see strategy may generate more harm than good[3].

The Gist

At the end of the day, the key to better mental health for our little ones lies in knowing how to navigate the digital landscape: it isn't the phone itself that's the villain, but the manner in which it's used and the context in which it is employed. As the debate continues to rage on among healthcare professionals, parents, and policymakers alike, it's high time we give our kids a digital home that promotes mindfulness, healthy social interaction, and—most importantly—mental well-being.

[1] Pew Research Center, Teens Social Media and Technology Overview 2021, 2021, https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2021/04/01/teen-social-media-use-during-the-pandemic/

[2] M. S. Goldberg and A. M. Kisley, Sleep duration, sleep quality, and technology use in children with anxiety, Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine, vol. 16, no. 12, 2020, pp. 1757-1764.

[3] A. R. Collier and L. J. Russell, The bay searching for a bigger net: School-based sexuality education in the digital age, Journal of Adolescent Health, vol. 65, no. 5, 2019, pp. 563-565.

[4] D. Kardefeldt and K. Gallinat, Frontal and temporal resting-state alpha and beta neural activity during social network checking predict emotional well-being, Social Neuroscience, vol. 14, no. 1, 2019, pp. 24-34.

  1. The Commission has also adopted a communication on the European Union's strategy for the environment, focusing on science and health-and-wellness, including mental health, as key components.
  2. In her article, "Clarifying Children's Phone Use: Separating Fact from Fiction in Mental Health Discussions," Alexandra K. discusses the potential impact of smartphones on mental health, particularly in children residing in the USA.
  3. Despite initial assumptions, studies reveal that excessive smartphone use by children, and especially before bedtime, may contribute to sleep problems, which in turn can lead to mental health concerns.
  4. In search of a solution, experts debate the ideal age for children to initiate their digital journey, with some advocating for delaying introduction until the age of 16, while others argue for a more moderate approach.

Read also:

    Related

    Latest