Trump's Order Sparks Debate: Oregon Law Boosts Institutionalization for Homelessness, Addiction, and Mental Illness
President Trump's recent executive order has sparked debate, urging states and local officials to boost the use of long-term institutionalization to tackle homelessness, crime, and disorder. Oregon has already enacted a new law to facilitate this process, but not everyone agrees with this approach.
The new law in Oregon allows judges to more easily commit individuals facing severe addiction or mental health issues to care, including institutionalization. However, Alton Aanderud, who has personal experience with these issues, worries about the potential overuse of civil commitment. He fears it could harm those it's intended to help, leaving them more vulnerable than before.
Judy Thompson, a prominent activist in Oregon, supports government-mandated hospital care for people with mental health issues. She believes it can prevent dangerous situations and help individuals before they hurt themselves or others. However, both she and Aanderud share concerns about the potential misuse of civil commitment and its negative impact on individuals, especially those without support systems.
Aanderud acknowledges that there were times when he needed civil commitment and institutional care. But he stresses that it should only be used when absolutely necessary and for the shortest possible period. President Trump, however, wants to increase the use of civil commitment to send more homeless Americans with addiction and mental health issues to institutions. A senior White House official has stated that the executive order will be implemented by states in ways that respect people's rights.
The debate surrounding President Trump's executive order and Oregon's new law highlights the complex nature of addressing homelessness, addiction, and mental health issues. While some see institutionalization as a solution, others warn of potential misuse and harm. The balance between care and individual rights remains a crucial issue to navigate.
